York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates

York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates

The “modern” York milled plates are iconic in the powerlifting world for their clean design, tight tolerances, and thin profile, allowing for more weight to be loaded on a standard bar. Known for their distinct milling used to calibrate weight, the larger plates often display appealing patterns on the back. While the smaller change plates also feature milling, it’s less common due to the difficulty of machining smaller plates without causing cracks. The design of the smaller plates mirrors that of earlier marked versions, with the notable exception of the 35 lb plate, where the markings face away from the hub.

Check Price

York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates Reviews

Based on 9 reviews from Gym Radar users, the York Barbell York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates have an average rating of 5.00 out of 5. They're currently the #3 most-owned Iron on Gym Radar, with 15 home gyms reporting ownership.

9 Reviews

5.00 / 5
Performance
5.00 / 5
Build Quality
5.00 / 5
Value
5.00 / 5

User Reviews

Leave a Review
user profile
Achievement badge
Big Ben Wyko
Wykos Gym
12 reviews
376 points
(5.00)
2/17/2026
York milled plates are sooo good. The best daily drivers you could ask for. Some would even say they are a gateway drug to collecting vintage weights. Get some and find out.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Hayden Lovelady
Misfits Barbell Club
72 reviews
815 points
(5.00)
2/17/2026
Came across a set of these in some old equipment purchased from a high school weight room.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Robo
The Cage
103 reviews
1077 points
(5.00)
2/16/2026
Was lucky enough to score a pair of these accidentally! Have rusted a bit but look great still and are accurate. If getting a set now id get rogue deep dish or strength co.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Brandon Doyle
O’Doyle Rules Barbell Club
121 reviews
1250 points
(5.00)
2/11/2026
These are awesome plates. Always a treat to use these at work when I’m at one of our gyms that have them. Just like the strength co plates that have a great sound when you have a few 45’s loaded up.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Kevin Rahill
Rahill Strong Gym
52 reviews
896 points
(5.00)
1/28/2026
Perhaps the best value weight plates you can find if you're willing to be patient on the used market. They are thin so you can fit a lot of plates on the bar. The milled backs make the plates both pretty accurate and very cool and iconic looking. The old school vibes are nearly unbeatable. If you see a gym with a set of York plates, you can't help but think "Yeah, this guy gets it"
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Hogan Gagle
Vienna Iron Club
226 reviews
2460 points
(5.00)
1/24/2026
If you are wanting some vintage weights in your gym for daily drivers that you are likely to find near you and at an okay price, these are great for that. The look and feel just screams strong. These are well worth considering as your main choice for plate.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Massenomics Tanner
Massenomics Gym
77 reviews
1042 points
(5.00)
1/23/2026
It's hard to improve from these. Made in America. Milled. Timeless look and feel. Still a very affordable used option. Pretty accurate weight.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Basement Brandon
Basement Barbell
222 reviews
1675 points
(5.00)
1/21/2026
These are some of the best plates ever made. Accurate, made in USA, and very aesthetic. These are also very affordable at around $1-$1.50/pound.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Keith Honeycutt - The No Whine Cellar
The No Whine Cellar
184 reviews
2211 points
(5.00)
1/15/2026
My daily driver plates for over a decade. If you can pick up milled era plates for $1-1.5 a lb jump on that deal. They are relatively accurate and not super hard to find and build your own collection.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

Official Massenomics Review

Gyms With This York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates

Loading gyms with this piece...

Other Pieces Like This

Loading similar pieces...

More From York Barbell

Loading more pieces from York Barbell...